The Bet Smart team blogs regularly about the iGaming & Betting Industry, product development, design & user experience, and the latest technology trends.

5 reasons we switched from Basecamp to Asana

Written by on November 20, 2013

At Bet Smart, we always have exciting yet complex projects on the go. Whether they are projects for other companies under our services business, or internal projects to build out our own products, we need to be organized. A focus on organization is especially important since we are often running multiple projects in parallel.

Luckily, there is a bevy of project management and collaboration tools out there to help us work in a more organized, collaborative manner. We’ve spent the last 12 months using one of the more popular tools, Basecamp, developed by the team at 37signals (who maintain the must-follow blog, Signal vs Noise). Basecamp is wildly popular, effective, and easy to use. However, our internal workflows have evolved, and with that we have outgrown the capabilities of Basecamp.

We spent a fair bit of time researching other options, reading user reviews, and taking the top ones for a test drive to see how the team here adapted to each. After the dust settled, we decided to make the switch from Basecamp to Asana, a relatively new entrant in the project management & collaboration space (which was started by one of Facebook’s original co-founders, Dustin Moskovitz).

Since adopting Asana as our go-to for project management, we have noticed quite a few benefits over Basecamp. Here are the top 5 reasons why it made sense for Bet Smart to switch from Basecamp to Asana:

1. Asana’s 3-column view lets us see everything at once

Asana lets you see everything in a single interface that uses a three-column structure of projects, tasks, and discussions. Basecamp requires users to navigate pages in order to switch between project tasks, making it difficult to see where that task fits in within the context of others. With Asana, every project is a single click away. Within each project, every task is immediately visible, and all comments, actions and files for a task are neatly organized in one place.

If you’d rather focus on just one project or a single task, Asana has recently upgraded its interface to let you minimize some columns to give the others more screen real estate.  This is really helpful when reading long discussions or modifying multiple nested task lists.

2. Google Drive integration

When a more detailed document is needed for a task, we often use Google Drive to collaborate on things like specification documents, spreadsheets, and architecture diagrams. Basecamp has its own text editor to create and save text documents relating to projects, which is basically just a notepad. Asana lets us easily attach these Google Drive files to tasks, which is a very handy feature for us. This is also useful since we often share those documents with external project stakeholders.

3. You can ditch your mouse when using Asana

Using Basecamp meant clicking around – a lot. Asana has eliminated the need to leave your keyboard when you are organizing and creating tasks using a series of available keyboard shortcuts for common actions.

To measure the impact of this, we can compare the steps needed to create a to-do list and add a task using each product:

In Basecamp:

  1. Click ‘Add a todo list”
  2. Type the title
  3. Click “Save and start adding todos”
  4. Type the todo
  5. Click “Add this todo”

In Asana:

  1. Type the title, ending with “:”
  2. Type the todo

With keyboard shortcuts, there are fewer steps to getting things done in Asana. Over weeks and months of managing projects, these little time saving steps add up!  Asana can be navigated purely with keyboard shortcuts, and it saves all your text as you write it.

4. Internal Linking of Tasks is Clean

Asana gives each new task a unique url, but when linking between tasks it uses anchor text with the name of the task.  Clicking an internal link opens the task without reloading the entire page, which makes everything feel very connected and organized. Basecamp requires users to paste an entire url, which is much less clean and is difficult to understand in the context of a discussion.  

5. It’s free!

Basecamp is not prohibitively expensive (plans start at $20/month), but Asana has a free service tier that actually provides more than enough to meet our needs.  Asana has a premium tier which allows for private projects, more tools, and guest accounts.  Even for the free accounts, Asana is rapidly upgrading and plugging more services into their product.  Hardly a week goes by where Asana doesn’t announce an upgrade or fix on their blog.

Reviews and the opinions of other users were great in helping us narrow down our choices for new project management software to try, but in the end, the one that we enjoy using the most and get the most out of is best for us.  Day to day project management is now faster and more organized than when we used Basecamp. Asana is a perfect companion to our progressing workflows as we manage new and exciting projects moving forward.

Jordan Tarasoff is a Product Manager at Bet Smart.

  • JackieBocha

    Asana + Bitrix24 = the best free productivity combo in the history of humanity

  • Pingback: Small pieces, loosely joined: Why everything should be URLs — Gigaom Research()

  • Bet Smart Media

    Thanks for the suggestion! We’ll check it out.

  • Derek

    How do you use both Asana + Bitrix24 together. I would LOVE to know! :) Thank you in advance

  • Dave Wormald

    We use Asana at Gabitat. Our task management requirements are fairly light and Asana’s interface is intuitive and didn’t take us long to learn. We liked it so much that we built an integration with our product!

  • Bet Smart Media

    Awesome! We hope to try out some integrations ourselves in the new year. Thanks for stopping by, and happy holidays!

  • Tobin Poppenberg

    Hey Jordan. Thanks SO much for this. It was EXACTLY what I needed to read. I’ve struggled SO much over not being able to have commenting features that google docs (drive) allows in collaborating with clients in docs in BaseCamp. This solves it for me! One suggestion. Your post comes up on the first page of search results when you search for Basecamp vs. Asana. This means it’s likely getting a TON of traffic, and as a marketer, I have to recommend that you populate the links to Asana (and Basecamp) with affiliate links so you can start generating money from the sales you’re UNDOUBTEDLY sending Asana. No clue what they offer, but you could be earning some cash, no doubt. Cheers!

    Tobin

  • Bet Smart Media

    Hey Tobin – thanks for commenting! Very glad to hear that the post was valuable for you. Indeed, the Google Drive/Docs integration was a huge one for us, which made Asana that much more appealing.

    Thanks as well for your suggestion about affiliate links. While we could probably earn some extra coffee money for ourselves, we’re happy enough leaving our comparison as an objective piece that helps people like you decide which tool is best for them! Besides, the folks at Asana deserve whatever signups they might get from the click-throughs :).

    Cheers & happy new year to you!

    Jesse

  • Estelle Aubel

    I switched from basecamp to proofhub.com and it seems to be the best alternative to basecamp. I have used this tool and it is really awesome.

  • Sarah Pimentel

    Hi! How did you migrate the content you previously had in basecamp to asana ?

  • Bet Smart Media

    Hi Sarah – We had to move all the content across manually, downloading files from basecamp and uploading them to asana as well as copying or rewriting tasks and discussions. It wasn’t the most elegant way to make the move, but as a bonus it helped us tidy up some cluttered projects we had in Basecamp!

  • jotham2

    On a team using Asana, and finding I miss the Discussion section of a project from Basecamp. Sure the conversation related to a task is easy to follow, but broader conversation winds up in chat or email. Did your team not use the Discussion section much, or how are you using Asana for project (but not task-specific) talk?

  • Bet Smart Media

    Often on a project we will create a section called “Discussions.” We then write the topic of the discussion as a task and discuss using the comment functionality.

  • http://markattwood.com Mark Attwood

    such a great article. Helped me make the switch – thank you. I’ve been on Asana for 2 days and already enjoying the switch :-)

  • Bet Smart Media

    Awesome, glad you found it useful, Mark!

  • Gabi

    I’d like to know this too, how can they be used together?

  • rae_trent

    Great article, Jordan! We use Asana at our company and it is definitely great for project management as well as collaboration. I’d like to point out, however, a program that is fairly new and we’re looking at called Centrallo. I’ve been using it for my personal organization and collaborating on shared lists with friends and family, but I have yet to make the whole office switch. Trying to see if others have had any experience with a Centrallo switch ?

  • Piyush Kedia

    I am curious to know as well how to use Asana+Bitrix24. I would appreciate if you could share more info. Thanks

  • http://www.sahilparikh.com/ Sahil Parikh

    Nice post Jordan. Have you tried Brightpod.com focused on marketing teams & agencies? I am the founder there and would like to invite you to take it for a spin.

  • Srikanth

    Asana = Task management.
    Bitrix24 = Team Collaboration.

    ScribLeaf = A combination of the above two + Information management + Lot more!

  • Srikanth

    A nice way of putting things in perspective. Nicely written Jordan. As I read through your ‘5-reasons’ I am convinced you will love the way ScribLeaf works. ScribLeaf is designed keeping these three things in mind.
    1. Meaningful Communication.
    2. Knowledge Management.
    3. Planning and Tracking of deliverables. (Task management)